Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing the menu at Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille is a delightful adventure into fresh, vibrant Mexican cuisine. Located in Selden, NY, the restaurant offers a casual environment perfect for groups and families, complete with outdoor seating and a dog-friendly policy. The menu boasts an array of mouthwatering appetizers like Tortilla Pizza and Jumbo Stuffed Peppers, while the tacos showcase a variety of flavors, from crispy chili meat to the innovative Taco Pescadero featuring breaded red snapper.

  • Quesadillas are standout favorites, especially the Buffalo Quesadilla and Birria Quesadilla.
  • Fresh ingredients make every dish shine, and the salsa bar offers endless choices to enhance your meal.

With something for everyone, from vegetarian options to robust meat dishes, Blue Tortilla promises a satisfying dining experience. Reviews highlight the freshness and authenticity, making it a must-visit for Mexican food lovers!

Appetizers

Tortilla Pizza

Crispy flour tortilla topped with melted Jack and cheddar cheese, sour cream, guacamole, fresh chopped tomato salsa and black beans. Add chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak for an extra charge.

$9.87

Nachos

Corn chips, black beans, topped with guacamole, sour cream, melted Jack and cheddar cheese, fresh chopped tomato salsa. Add chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak for an extra charge.

$14.02

Guacamole

1/2 lb. of large guacamole with chips.

$11.69

3 Fried Cheese

Mozzarella cheese wedges double breaded and deep-fried and served with guacamole.

$11.69

8 Mexi Wings

Seasoned wings. Served with Buffalo sauce, blue cheese and fresh celery.

$14.81

6 Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce.

$10.13

8 Fried Plantains

Sweet bananas, fried golden brown.

$8.83

Jumbo Stuffed Pepper

Green pepper stuffed with chili meat, rice, melted Jack cheese and fresh chopped tomato salsa.

$8.96

6 Coconut Shrimp

Coconut shrimp served with chipotle mayo.

$15.46

Tamales

Beef, chicken or pork in a green corn husk.

$7.27

Mexi Fries

French fries with melted Jack and cheddar cheese.

$10.13

Carne Asada Fries

Fries with sauteed onions, carne asada, nacho cheese, sour cream and guacamole.

$18.19

Cabo Calamari

Crispy, breaded calamari with chipotle mayo on the side.

$14.03

Taquitos

Chicken or chili meat rolled in corn tortillas and fried crispy served with guacamole, sour cream and fresh chopped tomato salsa.

$12.59

Jalapeo poppers (6)

Jalapeo stuffed with cheddar chs, served with sour cream

$11.17

Taco Crispy

Chili meat, chicken or steak in a crispy corn tortilla with lettuce, cheese, sour cream and fresh chopped tomato salsa.

$5.32

Taco Softie

Chicken, chili meat or steak, lettuce, cheese, sour cream and fresh chopped tomato salsa in a flour tortilla.

$5.70

Taco Classico

Soft corn tortilla, chopped onion and cilantro with hot or mild salsa with a choice of chicken, chorizo, chili meat or steak. Lime on the side.

$5.31

Taco Pescadero

Breaded red snapper, fresh chopped tomato salsa, cabbage and house dressing in a corn tortilla. Lime on the side.

$6.88

Taco Gamba

Sauteed shrimp in a corn tortilla, chopped onion and cilantro, with hot or mild sauce. Lime on the side.

$6.61

Taco de Lengua

Tongue taco. Beef tongue in a corn tortilla, chopped onion and cilantro, guacamole with hot or mild sauce. Lime on the side.

$6.62

Taco al Pastor

Marinated pork in a corn tortilla, chopped onion and cilantro, with hot or mild sauce. Lime on the side.

$6.62

2 Taco Perfectos

2 Tacos. Lettuce, sour cream, guacamole, cheese, fresh chopped tomato salsa, in a flour tortilla black beans with a choice of chicken, chili meat or steak.

$15.19

2 Taco Fajitas

2 Tacos. Sauteed onions and peppers, guacamole, Jack cheese with chicken or steak in a flour tortilla.

$14.03

2 Taco BBQ

2 Tacos. Pulled BBQ chicken, Jack cheese, lettuce and fresh chopped tomato salsa in a flour tortilla.

$11.98

2 Taco Veggie

2 Tacos. Black beans, corn, lettuce, tomato salsa, sliced avocado and cheese in a flour tortilla.

$13.78

2 Taco Avocado Fish

2 Tacos. Breaded red snapper, guacamole, chipotle mayo, lettuce, fresh chopped tomato salsa and Jack cheese.

$16.11

2 Taco Carnitas

2 Tacos. Pork, chopped onion & cilantro, guacamole, hot or mild sauce.

$14.03

Tacos

Quesadillas

Quesadilla

Melted Jack cheese in a flour tortilla. Add chicken, chorizo, vegetables , BBQ pork, steak or shrimp for an extra charge.

$12.59

Buffalo Quesadilla

Buffalo chicken, ranch, melted Jack and cheddar cheese in a flour tortilla.

$16.88

Loaded Quesadilla

Chicken, melted Jack and cheddar cheese in a flour tortilla with corn, black beans and zesty sauce.

$18.18

Blackened Quesadilla

Blackened chicken, melted Jack cheese in a flour tortilla. Spicy.

$21.05

BBQ Chicken Quesadilla

BBQ chicken, crispy onions and melted Jack cheese in a flour tortilla.

$18.18

Avocado Shrimp Quesadilla

Shrimp, avocado, corn, chipotle mayo, melted Jack and cheddar cheese in a flour tortilla.

$21.05

Birria Quesadilla

Chipotle braised beef, melted jack cheese, onions and cilantro in a flour tortilla served with fresh chopped tomato salsa, Guacamole and sour cream.

$18.71

Rice Bowl

Rice, black beans, sauteed onions and peppers topped with Jack cheese and fresh chopped tomato salsa. Choice of chicken, pulled pork, chili meat, steak or shrimp.

$16.88

Veggie Rice Bowl

Rice, black beans, corn, sauteed onions, peppers and mushrooms, topped with Jack cheese and fresh chopped tomato salsa.

$16.88

Chipotle Rice Bowl

Rice, black beans, corn, lettuce, guacamole, Jack cheese and chipotle mayo with chicken, chili meat or steak.

$14.30

Mexi Rice Bowl

Rice and melted cheese blend with chicken, steak or shrimp.

$16.88

Rice Bowls

Favorites and Platters

Enchiladas

2 soft tortillas in a green tomatillo sauce topped with cheese, rice, beans, fresh chopped tomato salsa, lettuce and sour cream with chicken or chili meat, steak or shrimp.

$19.62

Chimichangas

Jumbo fried burrito topped with melted cheese, rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream and guacamole with chicken, pulled pork, chili meat, steak or shrimp.

$20.14

Mexican Torta

Rollo. Toasted roll with chicken or steak, sour cream, guacamole, lettuce and tomato. Served with french fries.

$14.80

Tortilla Platter

Rice, beans, lettuce, sliced avocado, cheese, fresh chopped tomato salsa, flour tortillas with chicken, steak or shrimp.

$19.61

Fajita Platter

Sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, rice, beans, cheese, guacamole and flour tortillas. Chicken, steak, shrimp, shrimp and chicken or shrimp and steak.

$21.04

Tostada Salad

Tortilla shell stuffed with lettuce, beans, guacamole, sour cream, Jack cheese and fresh chopped tomato salsa. Add chicken, pork, chili meat, steak or shrimp for an extra charge.

$14.03

Tortilla Salad

Charbroiled chicken, lettuce, crushed corn chips, fresh chopped tomato salsa and shredded cheddar cheese with a side of Italian dressing.

$16.24

Fresca Salad

Charbroiled chicken, lettuce, corn, sliced avocado, Jack and cheddar cheese with a side of ranch dressing.

$18.18

BBQ Chicken Salad

Chicken sauteed in BBQ sauce with sauteed onions, lettuce, corn, avocado, Jack and cheddar cheese with a side of ranch dressing.

$18.18

Fajita Salad

Lettuce, sauteed mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes and onions, cheese and guacamole with chicken, steak or shrimp.

$19.62

House Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onion and black olives.

$12.59

Salads

Burritos

Burrito Loco

Rice, black beans, Jack cheese, sour cream and fresh chopped tomato salsa with chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak.

$15.19

Burrito Mexicali

Rice, corn, Jack cheese, guacamole, fresh chopped tomato salsa and fresh lime juice with chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak.

$15.45

Burrito Fajita

Sauteed mushrooms, bell peppers, tomatoes and onions, Jack cheese and guacamole with chicken or steak.

$15.46

Burrito Blackened Chicken

Blackened chicken, rice, black beans, sour cream, crispy onions, lettuce and cheddar cheese. Spicy.

$17.53

Burrito Barbacoa

Shredded beef, rice, black beans, Tapatio hot sauce, sour cream, lettuce and Jack cheese.

$16.88

Burrito Vegetariano

Rice, black beans, lettuce, guacamole, fresh chopped tomato salsa, sour cream and Jack cheese.

$14.02

Burrito California

French fries, corn, sour cream, guacamole, Jack and cheddar cheese with chicken, pulled pork, chilli meat or steak.

$15.45

Burrito Classico

Melted Jack cheese, guacamole and fresh chopped tomato salsa with chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak.

$13.77

Burrito Chorizo

Chorizo, rice, pinto beans, salsa verde, onion and cilantro, sour cream and cheddar cheese.

$15.45

Burrito Pulled Pork

Pulled pork, rice, pinto beans, lettuce, guacamole, salsa verde and Jack cheese.

$15.45

Burrito Grande

Rice, onion and cilantro, mild or hot salsa, beans with chicken, pulled pork, chili meat or steak.

$14.03

Burrito Cozumel

Sauteed green peppers, mushrooms, onions, jalapenos, sliced avocado and chipotle mayo with chicken or steak. Spicy.

$15.20

Burrito Gamba

Sauteed shrimp, melted Jack and cheddar cheese, sauteed onions, rice, cabbage sour cream and sliced avocado.

$18.96

Burrito Cabo Shrimp

Cajun shrimp, rice, black beans, guacamole, zesty sauce and Jack cheese. Spicy.

$18.96

Burrito Pescadero

Breaded red snapper, fresh chopped tomato salsa, cabbage and chipotle mayo.

$18.18

Burrito Avocado Fish

Breaded red snapper, rice, pinto beans, guacamole, chipotle mayo, lettuce, fresh chopped tomato salsa and Jack cheese.

$18.96

Burrito Calamari

Crispy breaded calamari, fresh chopped tomato salsa, cabbage and chipotle mayo.

$18.18

12" Long Burrito Mucho

Rice, black beans, sauteed peppers and onions, Jack cheese, sour cream and tomato salsa, with chicken, chili meat or steak.

$24.03

Chicken Avocado Wrap

Chicken, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo.

$14.38

Mexican Chicken Wrap

Chicken with peppers, Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$13.18

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, lettuce, parmigiana cheese and Caesar dressing.

$13.18

Veggie Wrap

Sauteed mushrooms, bell peppers, tomatoes and onions, lettuce, avocado and vinaigrette dressing.

$13.18

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Chicken sauteed in our Buffalo sauce with blue cheese, lettuce and celery.

$13.18

Shrimp Wrap

Sauteed shrimp, lettuce, onion, tomato, avocado and balsamic vinaigrette.

$15.58

Tortilla Wraps

Empanadas

Chicken Empanada

Filled with pulled chicken.

$4.42

Buffalo Chicken Empanada

Mozzarella cheese, pulled chicken and Buffalo sauce.

$5.45

BBQ Chicken Empanada

Pulled chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon and mozzarella cheese.

$5.45

Philly Cheesesteak Empanada

Steak, sauteed onions with Jack and cheddar cheese.

$5.45

Steak Fajita Empanada

Steak sauteed with peppers and onions.

$5.45

Chicken Fajita Empanada

Chicken sauteed with peppers and onions.

$5.45

Cheesy Chicken Empanada

Pulled chicken with mozzarella cheese.

$5.45

Chili Meat Empanada

Filled with chili meat.

$4.42

Cheesy Chili Empanada

Chili meat with mozzarella cheese.

$5.45

Chorizo Papas Empanada

Chorizo, potatoes, mozzarella cheese and mexican spices.

$5.45

Cheese Empanada

Filled with mozzarella cheese.

$4.42

Cheese Lover Empanada

Monterey Jack cheese, cheddar cheese and mozzarella cheese.

$5.45

Mexican Empanada

Pinto beans, cheddar cheese and Spanish rice.

$5.45

Maduro Empanada

Sweet plantains and mozzarella cheese.

$5.45

Oreo Empanada

Oreo pieces and chocolate syrup.

$5.45

Kids Mini Quesadilla

Served with rice and corn. Add chicken or steak for an extra charge.

$7.77

Kids 2 Crispy Tacos

Ground beef, lettuce and cheese.

$7.06

Kids Mini Burrito

Chicken, rice and cheese.

$8.38

Kids 2 Soft Tacos

Ground beef, lettuce and cheese.

$8.00

Kids Chicken Fingers

Served with french fries.

$9.00

For the Kids

Sides

Black Beans

$3.45

Pinto Beans

$3.45

Corn

$3.45

Rice

$3.45

Chips with Salsa

$5.20

French Fries

$5.98

1/2 lb. Sauteed Veggies

$5.49

1/2 lb. Chicken

$6.10

1/2 lb. Steak

$7.80

1/2 lb. Chili Meat

$5.84

1/2 lb. Shrimp

$10.90

Nacho Cheese

$4.29

1 Tortilla

$0.39

Side of Sour Cream

$1.11

Chicken Vegetable

Tender chicken pieces, tomatoes, onions and peppers in a chicken stock.

$6.74

Chili Soup

Tender beef simmered with diced tomatoes, kidney beans, onions and cilantro, select chilis and Mexican spices topped with cheddar cheese.

$7.00

Tortilla Soup

Tomatoes, onions, peppers and cilantro topped with fried tortilla strips.

$6.10

Black Bean Soup

Black beans, onions, avocado, garlic, lime and bell peppers.

$7.90

Mexi-Chili

Homemade chili topped with Monterey Jack cheese, sour cream and side of chips.

$9.10

Soups and Chilis

Desserts

Churros

$2.98

Sopapillas

$4.78

Flan

$4.78

Tres Leches

$5.99

Xangos

Cheesecake.

$5.99

Bottled Soda

$2.99

Bottled Water

$2.99

Jarrito Soda

Mexican soda.

$3.49

2 Liter Soda

$4.19

Beverages

Family Dinner

Family Dinner

Serves 3-4 people. Chicken, steak, pulled pork or chili meat served with rice, black beans, cheese, corn, fresh chopped tomato salsa, lettuce, blue tortilla salsa, sour cream, guacamole, chips and 2-liter soda with ten 6" flour tortillas.

$51.99